CHINA TO THE US: STOP WITH THE MONOPOLY MONEY
NEW YORK – November 13, 2010
One day, the king of ancient Babylon summoned his treasury overseer and exclaimed, “I need more money to wage war on those Hittite terrorists! “I looked in the great treasure chest and it’s nearly empty. There are hardly any gold coins left,” he thundered.
“Oh Light of the Euphrates,” groveled his terrified minister, “we are out of gold. Your wars have become too expensive.”
 
“But I have a solution, your celestial greatness. We will quietly trim the amount of gold in our imperial gold coins to make them go further. No one will notice.”
 
Fast forward to Washington, 2010.   It’s no longer called “clipping coins.” Today, the name for debauching a nation’s currency is called “quantitative easing(QE),” but it’s still the same old fraud committed by financial flim-flam men.    
 
Washington is flooding financial markets with $600 billion of worthless dollars, hoping a rising tide of Monopoly money will somehow lift America out of recession. The Fed’s first QE effort was a fizzle.
 
The US government is stoking worldwide inflation in order to lower its outstanding debt by repaying creditors with depreciated dollars.  The rest of the world is boiling angry at Washington.
 
Just before last week’s G20 economic summit in South Korea, China’s state credit agency publicly downgraded America’s credit rating and questioned US leadership of the world’s economy. 
 
In an unprecedented, stinging rebuke, China  scolded Washington for “deteriorating debt repayment capability,” and predicted quantitative easing would lead to “fundamentally lowering the national solvency.” 
 
Wow! This was a  real slap in the face heard around the globe. China is the largest holder of US government debt.  I remember the day when New York financiers used to sneer at iffy stock or bond issues as, “Chinese paper.”  Now, it’s “American paper.” How the world has turned.
 
Washington has been blasting China for manipulating its currency to keep the value low – which is quite true. Embarrassingly, Germany and Brazil just accused the US of  being as big a currency manipulator as China – which is also quite true.
 
A depreciated dollar boosts US exports and hurts nations exporting to the US. Economists call it, “beggar thy neighbor,” a destructive trade practice that played a key role in the 1930’s world depression.
 
This money flood is eroding the value of the dollar, the world’s premier medium of exchange. In the past two months, the US dollar has dropped 6% against other major currencies. Frightened investors are piling into gold, now up 17% in 60 days. 
 
The Obama administration, just “shellacked” by voters in mid-term elections, and desperate to lower unemployment, is gambling more debt shock therapy will spark the economy  back to life. But massive, unsustainable debt caused the US financial meltdown in 2008.
 
The US public debt has hit a stratospheric $14 trillion.   You don’t treat a poisoning victim with more poison. 
 
But panicky politicians are ready to try any sort of economic snake oil remedy to save their skins. Before 2007, America was living high on phony financial froth. Finance had become America’s leading business. Those days are over but no one dares tells voters.
 
Besides destabilizing world exchange rates and trade, Washington’s money flood is pouring into emerging markets as American investors seek higher returns than the miserable .03% available at home.   
 
During the 1980’s, we saw fragile Asian economies battered as investment from the US flooded in, then out. This is happening again, boosting currencies of many nations, making their exports uncompetitive. Investments barriers are going up from China to Brazil. 
 
President Barack Obama inherited a horrible mess from the Bush administration. However, his wrongheaded economic response is undermining the world’s economic order. A nation’s currency is more a symbol of its strength and good name than its flag. Running down the US dollar, which ruled world finance since 1945, could mark the beginning of the end of the American era.
 
That’s what the American delegation to the G20 economic summit in Seoul, South Korea heard this week. Obama’s economic policies, notably his attempts to stimulate the US economic with the steroids of more deficit spending, were roundly rejected and criticized by other G20 members.
 
However, there was an uncommon  flash of common sense in Washington last week. A special bi-partisan presidential panel on reducing the national deficit proposed $4 trillion in federal spending cuts. 
 
All political sacred cows were targeted. The biggest: the $700 billion military budget. A third of US worldwide military bases would close. There would be cuts to social security,  mortgage deductions, delays in retirement age,  an end to politician’s local pet projects. Taxes would rise.
 
The howling has already begun. Unfortunately, such unpopular, drastic spending cuts seem highly unlikely, particularly in the new US Congress where Republicans and Democrats will be deadlocked.  America would need an economic dictator to implement the panel’s full plan.  
 
So it seems the US will stagger along under a mountain of unsustainable debt while the world economy suffers widening shocks and turmoil.  
 
More empires have been undone by financial collapse than invasion or battlefield defeats. The once mighty United States is staggering in this direction
 
copyright Eric S. Margolis 2010
Mayor Quimby
Saturday, November 13, 2010 6:22 PM
All caused by Bush, but the rednecks will blame Obabma.
Mike Smith
Saturday, November 13, 2010 7:42 PM
Obama is really no better, he did nothing to change course so he should eat his share of the blame
tn
Sunday, November 14, 2010 12:27 PM
Superman would find the job of president, as it now stands, impossible.

The president is a figure head whose strings are pulled by massively entrenched interests (multiple) who have raped the American economy and people.

Eric is perfectly right. It would take an "economic dictator" or a modern French revolution to force the issue. Many will suffer greatly.

Before the nuclear age, world problems such as we are experiencing tended to lead towards war between first world nations.

We are now deep into uncharted waters.



Cicero
Sunday, November 14, 2010 9:53 PM
Obama is just a bumboy Mike.He does what he is told or else.But he allowed himself to be used and will be richly rewarded for his betrayal.A lot of white people voted for him,because he is such a suave orator,but he betrayed the people of color most of all.For a few days they honestly believed,that some semblance of equality had finally come,only to get kicked in the face again.And the gullible American people think now,that they get a better deal with the Republicans at the helm again.Sometimes I think,you can really fool all the people all of the time.At least this way,they can blame the demise of this crazy empire on a non-white.Some consolation.
Vandellish
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 12:41 PM
As a proud, independent, progressive black man from the US I wholeheartedly endorse this message.
But I knew it...It's why I voted for Cynthia McKinney two years ago.
RadicalRaul
Wednesday, November 24, 2010 1:38 PM
God forbid should the top tier earners, aka the rich elite ruling class pay their fair share to help pay down the debt.

Patrick Seamus
Thursday, December 09, 2010 10:41 AM
Actually, all caused by Wilson, Roosevelt, Truman, Eisenhower, Johnson, Nixon, Ford, Carter, Reagan, Bush, Clinton, Bush and Obama. Kennedy gets a pass for Executive Order 11110. Everyone else on the above list did nothing but drive the nation further into debt to international bankers.
weldon hodgins
Saturday, November 13, 2010 7:37 PM
What could we possibly do with $14 trillion worth of kitty litter?
Mike Smith
Saturday, November 13, 2010 7:43 PM
Need something to soak up all the blood thats coming
J Hoell
Saturday, November 13, 2010 8:50 PM
Anyone with a little bit of common sense and minimal financial knowledge, (no Einstein needed here),would have seen this happening 20 or 30 years in the making.It is never important how much money you are able to borrow....but HOW MUCH you are able to pay back.It just boggles my mind when even an average person brags to their friends that their credit limit has been increased on their credit card.Wonderful.....now after making minimum monthly payments for some time now, they are "offered" this exclusive offer by their financial institution,and their debt grows by leaps and bounds.This is no different than what has happened here, as Eric has accurately informed his readers about, now that America's debt has reached the point of no return without an awful lot of bleeding that will result.There simply is no other way...America,in the eyes of the world,has already achieved third world country status.I just shudder to think what is going to happen during the next (last) two years of Obama's presidency as he will be taking the fall for this.This is one scenario where only an iron fisted "dictator" will be needed to clean up this financial mess in America.Hundreds of desperate politicians debating day and night are NOT going to solve this crisis....they are all going to look after their own ass first.If anyone thinks that the economy is "turning around" in America,and thinks that "things are starting to look up" is a fool in the truest sense of the meaning.Again my sincere thanks to Eric for an article that every American citizen should read.....and heed.
Mathias
Sunday, November 14, 2010 12:23 AM
We've long passed the point where it is politically possible to balance the US budget. We are reaching the point now where it is mathematically impossible to balance the budget. Taxes would have to be doubled, most of the military shut down, and serious, serious cuts made in social security. Even then if interest rates rise, and they will, all the budget cutting will be for nought because interest payment increases would be in the hundreds of billions. It's obvious that they are going to devalue the currency, and anyone who loaned the US money is a) very angry and b) totally screwed. If the US doesn't default you will get your money back, sans all it's purchasing power.
Ivan Lussier
Sunday, November 14, 2010 10:42 AM
The following paragraphs appeared in the Toronto Star yesterday, Nov. 13, 2010 under the headline:
Israel’s Netanyahu unveils U.S. plan for new talks.

….The Obama administration would also ask Congress to approve the supply of $3 billion worth of warplanes to Israel “to maintain its qualitative edge” in the region, the source said.
The United States would further sign a more comprehensive deal to enhance its substantial security aid to Israel as part of any agreement concluded with the Palestinians….
-------- Even if the U.S. is going bankrupt, it seems it is ready to spend billions to reach an Israel/Palestinian settlement. But is it? I thought that IsraeI is already a strong power in the Middle East. I think that, underneath all this, the U.S. and Israel are probably getting ready to attack Iran! I hope I'm wrong. God, will this ever end? --------
J Hoell
Sunday, November 14, 2010 11:04 AM
@Ivan....Israel's PM Netanyahu has made it perfectly CLEAR that he does not want a Palestinian homeland,in other words NO PEACE....need I say more? These "peace talks" are merely a smoke and mirrors scherade....nothing else.As far as attacking Iran goes,you are probably correct.....for wars,America always finds the "necessary" funds.
Ivan Lussier
Sunday, November 14, 2010 2:01 PM
Yes J.H., I agree with you. The hope for peace is very small. The expansion of the settlements in the Occupied Territories is still going on – stopped only for a period of time when Netanyahu wants to resume the peace process; then forcing the Palestinians to end the talks by lifting the moratorium. This will end only when the Israeli government’s goal has been achieved. I might be wrong, but I see deceit in Netanyahu. Then there is Jerusalem which is the culminate point that will probably put an end to whatever was accomplished, in the peace process, up to now. Sad reality!
The Work Farce
Sunday, November 14, 2010 11:47 AM
I often wonder how the economic meltdown happened only six weeks before Obama became president. Did the Bush administration and/or Wall Street make it happen that way to destroy Obama's plans for big changes? Remember how dumb John McCain sounded when asked how he would fix the economy, assuring Obama's victory? Recessions occur regularly every 10 years. That's no co-incidence. They are planned that way. Was this last big one deliberately pushed ahead a year or two for all the obvious reasons. Every institution in America, every bastion of wealth and privilege, from the military-industrial-media complex to the universities and the financial industry feared that their status quo power would be undermined by a strong Obama presidency. Recessions don't just happen, they are made to happen every 10 years. To keep inflation and wages low, unemployment and fear high. Recessions keep the economy of fear, greed and scarcity even more fearful, greedy and scarce.Recessions are perfect excuses to rob the poor to give to the rich. Decrease welfare and increase corporate welfare. Destroy social programs. It might be called economic terrorism. Even more than fear of a terrorist attack, Americans and the rest of the world fear losing their job, bankruptcy, homelessness and unaffordable health care. This current load of all of the above is just what the powers that be want. To whip the masses into fear, greed and wage drudgery. Political gridlock further advances economic greedlock, fear and hatred, divisiveness among the masses. The message is government is the problem, politics is the devil and the only prayer is to get a second job, work harder, submit to the religion of consumerism. Resistance is futile. Are recessions cyclical accidents or deliberately manipulated melt downs?
scissorpaws
Sunday, November 14, 2010 12:33 PM
The Chinese are the ones to talk, managing to keep their Yuan cheap by buying all those US dollars to keep it high. Let them begin to sell at any time. They won't because it will devalue all the remaining currency they own. This is all Bush's doing. He took the Clinton surplus and blew it all on idiot wars and the Republican congress and senate cheered him on. No talk of deficits in those days, it was all tax cuts. The US economy is in a slump and must stimulate now to raise GDP to balance the books. You can't pull an Ireland (or England) and expect to increase revenue by shutting down the economy. I believe Paul Krugman's prescription, that the US pledge to keep inflation at 5% every year for the next five years. Investors will quit sitting on their dollars.
Archie Knaud
Monday, November 15, 2010 7:27 AM
Anyone who lived through the depression, the war and it's aftermath or even the dreary fifties when almost noone had credit or dared to use it would be afraid of hard times. Porridge and patches,real food and work on saturdays.Stay at home vacations.Fix it yourself and take the bus .I remember my Dad walked 8 miles to work and back when we lived in a converted barn in the country .My brother went to a one room school and used chalk on small boards to learn lettering.Today he writes programs for computers.We awoke to find the windows coated with ice on the inside. So bring it on.Who cares?Crash the dollar and let China compete fair and sqare.Their cheating ways are coming to an end.
Dik
Monday, November 15, 2010 7:45 PM
Archie... are you an American, by chance... you sound like one.

The balance of trade is but a small part of the problem. By making the statement, `Bring it on`, you clearly don`t understand the magnitude of the problem The US is hurting with 10-15% unemployment... can you imagine the problems with 50 or 60%. I understand that it wasn`t until the early `60`s that the US had recovered from the 1930 crash...

I suspect that if China could get rid of all the American paper it holds without bringing the house of cards down, it would have done so. They are trapped holding a huge fortune in `worthless` funds...

I understand that just a short time before the Americans invaded Iraq, that Hussein was contemplating a switch to the Euro...

Quit blaming others for the shortcomings and greed of the US. It`s time to crawl out of the gutter without bringing the rest of the world down.
J Hoell
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 11:19 AM
Dik...what you have written makes a great deal of sense....wisely put into perspective.Now if only MORE people would realize the true magnitude of the problems created by America's desire to dictate and dominate world affairs.
Mike Smith
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 4:56 PM
I would suggest China has been getting rid of its useless American paper for some time now,

Have a look at Chinese foreign investing,

They have bought out the retreating American companys in several resourse ventures here in Canada and around the world.

Trading the nothing paper back for stakes in REAL enterprises which will hold some value during and after the crash to come.
Dik
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 11:26 PM
If I were a company being bought out by the Chinese.... I'd insist on their currency!
Mike Smith
Thursday, November 18, 2010 3:44 AM
Why, unless we go away from the US dollar in ALL transactions...

which would be a great idea, but only after we position ourselves for it.

Treat everyone the same, and many of these problems wouldn't have come to be in the first place.
Dik
Sunday, November 21, 2010 12:15 AM
I suspect that the US dollar will be continuing to decline, whereas the Chinese currency will only increase in value and if more people were to do this, the US dollar would further devaluate and the Chinese would be under more pressure to increase the value of their currency.

Why get paid in currency that will be worth less by the time the cheque clears the bank?
43*45'42"N79*24'25"W
Monday, November 28, 2011 2:48 PM
Dik

The Renmimbi would only increase in value if the Chinese Govt. would allow their currency to float in the world capital markets. They will NOT let if float, EVER. The Govt's No. 1 priority is Domestic. Keep the Chinese people working, and CREATE new jobs for the millions that migrate to the cities each year from their dismal life as peasant farmers.

Thus they must sell those products that the factories make. That is guaranteed with a favourable exchange rate.

The Chinese I suspect are buying hard assets in Africa, such as copper deposits, etc by bribing corrupt administrations with American Treasury Bills. Build mines, bridges, roads and hospitals with American dollars that they received by selling their Treasury Bills at a discount. Better to get rid of the "Treasury Bill Paper" at a discount, and receive US Greenbacks that are still preferred by workers in any country; more often than not because of inflation in their own currencies.

China is playing a smart game. Ingratiate themselves with foreign countries administrations by building infrastructure and creating jobs for their people. Chilna in turn gets the bulk of the commodity and shares the profit in a partnership with the (usually despotic) current elite who are the government.

If you get paid in discounted Treasury Bills you will have "built-in" inflation protection. Or you could request payment in "Hard specie". ie. - Gold or Silver.

Yours Respectfully
Archie Knaud
Thursday, November 18, 2010 7:20 PM
I'm Canadian.There wont be 50% unemployment.There will be hard times for a time and we will ajust.We will not become a third world nation because we are not a third world nation.China needs to float it's currency, in my opinion.That keeps it fair.The dollar needs to go down now and it will go up later when it becomes clear that the problems are being solved.
Dik
Thursday, November 18, 2010 7:51 PM
Archie... I hope you're correct, because the consequences are dire...and, yes, China needs to float it's currency, but that's not the cause of the problems...

A drunken sailor can only spend so much, and you can't blame the bartender... he's only making a living. People buying stuff in Chinese currency, or insisting on it, will put further pressure on Chinese currency, and it will naturally increase in value. The US, by printing money, will only dilute the value of their currency and anyone selling commodities and accepting US dollars as payment will loose; they will be worth less (not to be read as worthless) at the end of the day.

As far as clearing up the US problems... I have yet to see this... they seem to going from one crisis to another... they are like a centipede... just waiting for the next shoe to fall.
Archie Knaud
Thursday, November 18, 2010 8:19 PM
I'm sure we will survive all this.Yes you are correct we have spent ourselves into trouble.Time to pay the piper.The piper will get paid because we have no choice.A new world is unfolding before us and new opputunities will draw many away from the USA and its highly paid workers.The dollar may crash or just slide down for a time.After that it will recover because the USA will continue to be a rich and productive land and its people hard working and well educated.They're like the Yankees ,always in it.I do think however that being #1 is harder now due to expansion that's all.
Dik
Sunday, November 21, 2010 12:17 AM
Unfortunately, many of the people hurt will not be responsible for the problem and many of those taking advantage of the situation will be ones direvtly causing the problem.
Mike Smith
Friday, November 19, 2010 12:18 AM
As China, Germany and Brazil pointed out, over the last fifty years the Americans have been the biggest currency manipulator.

To solve the problems, we need to make things more simple, and with all the lawyers and lobbyists involved that won't happen.

Fair works both ways, don't blame China when they decide to play the same game with more skill than the Yanks.
J Hoell
Friday, November 19, 2010 9:25 AM
You do have a point,Mike....but when two(? )(maybe one) economic powerhouses try to fight fire with fire,there are ripple effects that,ultimately affect most of the world's economies and this is the last thing our fragile global economy can afford right now.I don't want to give Washington any ideas....but last year when GM declared bankruptcy,pretty much all of their existing debts were "erased" and a month later emerged as a "new company".Yesterday GM started offering to sell stocks and the prices are higher than they had anticipated.....scratch your head on that one....I already have a bald spot on my head.
J Hoell
Friday, November 19, 2010 11:20 AM
Hopefully there won't be 50% unemployment in Canada....never say never.Unless the US get's it's financial matters in order,which is highly unlikely in the forseeable future,then Canada's economy is going to continue to suffer because we depend too much on exports to the US.There are other factors involved here,naturally.But higher unemployment,especially Ontario,is going to be around for a while yet.
Zeeshan
Monday, November 15, 2010 4:04 PM
In grade 3, I often wondered why our government did not simply print more money to pay for things. Unfortunately, I was over-qualified for any financial role in government, as I had graduated to grade 4.
Dik
Monday, November 15, 2010 7:03 PM
The unregulated greed of a few individuals has brought the world to the brink of a potential financiaol disaster! It`s not a pleasant thought, but we are teetering and the slightest nudge can precipitate a financial crash, greatly exceeding the earlier depression of the `30`s.

We were taught that money was a means of storing labour... there was the barter system that worked as long as both components had something the other wanted. Money was developed as a means of storing labour so that I could buy Bill`s cow, instead of Fred`s pig, because I didn`t need a pig today.The system became tilted as soon as people could store vast amounts of labour without doing any work or producing a tangible commodity.
Zeeshan
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 9:50 AM
When it became obvious that actual money being printed and circulated did not represent the true amount of gold reserves, the gold standard was replaced with the American standard; America’s name was worth more than gold, because you were ensured a good barter if you wanted to cash your American tender note.

If America loses the glittery image and innovation/manufacturing continues to occur in other countries that can produce the same goods and services at better prices…..then the American standard will fall from grace. This reality has already set into motion, as the US dollar continues to decline from over-printing, over-borrowing and over-spending.
Cicero
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 9:34 PM
@ Dik,
If only I could say:"Dik,you are so wrong in your assessment of the present situation".But unfortunately I cannot say that,because all the signs and the writing on the wall say you are right.The maneuvers the US are making now seem Quichotic at best.How could such a great nation meet such a pityfull demise?It seems,that somewhere some powerful people got blackmailed into forfeiting the sovereignty of the entire country to some evil entity.America could never have attained such great heights of power and admiration by being stupid.Like the Roman Empire,the American one seems to be heading for the same grave and for the same reasons;total moral decay.Get out of your colonies and bring all your troops home,before there won`t be one left to come home to.
philmar
Thursday, November 18, 2010 12:33 PM
Moral decay indeed. Like Rome and it's circuses , the North American people are more concerned about music videos, NASCAR, football, video games or reality TV than the fact they are becoming bankrupt while invading countries without ties to terrorisist and devoid of weapons of mass destruction. Most are oblivious to the fact that fheir political process is controlled by financial interests through campaign donations. The discombobulation will NOT be televised.
Dolum
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 7:34 PM
The dollar has to devalue. I repeat, the dollar has to devalue.
The reason American steel mills have been shipped to China is because the dollar was overvalued. When we cannot compete in the mfg of steel, we are automatically out
of the running for kitchen appliances, pipe, tools, farm equipment and cars.

And China is screaming about it, because its 9% growth rate cannot continue with a
cheaper dollar. In fact, they probably already see the recession at the end of this growth cycle and cringe.

I positively hate it that America will be going through this depression in 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, and probably 2014 and 2015, but on the other end of it we will have jobs, jobs that make things out of steel, jobs that hire the 25% of our people below the age of 25 that are out of work and place them in positions where they can do more than flip burgers or shuffle papers.

The cheap dollar’s time has come.
J Hoell
Tuesday, November 16, 2010 9:43 PM
When trouble looms,you should always go back to the basics.....buy only what you can afford....if you need to borrow money,borrow wisely and ONLY what you are able to pay back.....don't borrow money for the wrong reasons.....and lastly, don't invade other soverign countries because you want control of their natural resources, just because you think that you are superior......because you're NOT.....just look at America.
43*45'42"N79*24'25"W
Monday, November 28, 2011 3:23 PM
Dolum

Please read my reply to Dik above.

The exchange rate between the US Dollar and the Renminbi will remain the same or very nearly the same. If the Dollar is devalued by inflation, or as Eric mentioned the new term in his piece "quantitative easing", the controlled Renminbi will simply devalue also. Remember the spiral that occured among Thailand, Cambodia, Indonesia, Malaysia and Viet Nam, and China when Thailand devalued its Baht to increase its exports, and China countered by devaluing its Renminbi. The other countries had to follow suit to keep their share of Exports to Rich First World countries. China won of course and the end product for them all was an increase in the cost of foreign imports; especially energy, ie. oil or oil products such as diesel, kerosene and gasoline.

Yours Respectfully
Archie Knaud
Thursday, November 18, 2010 8:33 PM
Don't get too hot on China.It's doing OK right now but it's still a repressive dictatorship.It executes disidents,fires live rounds into demonstrators and imprisons anyone who dares to speak up.It's a time bomb ticking.Oh yes,it creates jobs and steal our industries away right now but we have not seen them run a free election or declare human rights a priority.You have no reason to love them YET.
Seasile
Friday, November 19, 2010 9:15 AM
It's bad enough for the US to have evolved into a nation of narcissists but to imitate, follow and promote their new-age investment alchemey identifies many other countries as complaisant monetary hooligans. For America as we new it ...the end is near.
Mike Smith
Friday, November 19, 2010 12:02 PM
even worse

http://english.aljazeera.net/indepth/opinion/2010/11/20101116121343388841.html

"I'm with you, not my president," Eric Cantor told Israel's Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu

Soon-to-be House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-VA) is desperately trying to explain away the promise he made to Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu last Wednesday.

Cantor huddled with Netanyahu just prior to the Prime Minister's meeting with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

Clinton was expected to reaffirm the American commitment to Israeli-Palestinian negotiations and opposition to Israeli settlement expansion.


There are currently 42 comments
Comments Commentaries
Currently Ordered By:
Commentaries by Category