WILL THE US BACK REAL DEMOCRACY IN EGYPT?
January 28, 2012
Last Monday, Egyptians celebrated the first anniversary of the revolution that overthrew the 30-year Mubarak regime.

By contrast, America’s reaction this historic event was tellingly muted.

Egypt contains a quarter of the Arab world’s people. In Egypt, the US had a golden opportunity to encourage genuine democracy. Instead, it long opposed demands by Egyptians for real democracy and an end to Mubarak’s police state.

Egyptians know this. I recently stood among crowds of demonstrators in Cairo’s Tahrir Square, watching growing anger against the United States.

In the recent elections, Egypt’s venerable Muslim Brotherhood won some 48% of the parliamentary vote, confirming it as the primary voice of 81 million Egyptians. In North America, the Brotherhood has long been wrongly branded an extremist, even terrorist organization by partisans of Israel.

The Muslim Brotherhood is primarily composed of middle class, middle-aged doctors, engineers, lawyers. It is seriously stodgy and conservative. Many younger Egyptians derided it as “your grandfather’s party.” It sits squarely in the middle of Egypt’s political spectrum.

The Brotherhood’s political arm, its new Freedom and Justice Party, was patterned on Turkey’s highly successful, Islamic-lite AK Party of Prime Minister Recep Erdogan. Like Turkey’s AK, the Muslim Brotherhood is primarily concerned with fighting corruption, education, health and welfare - areas badly neglected by the former regime.

So far, the Brotherhood has not challenged the United States or Europe except for calling for justice for the Palestinians. But this, of course, was the primary reason why the US kept dictator Husni Mubarak in power for thirty years: he secretly colluded with Israel, and opposed US foes Iran and Syria.

Interestingly, the Brotherhood has been in close contact with Egypt’s military to work out a power-sharing deal. An accord between the two power centers is possible, provided the military ends its repression and cedes some important powers to parliament.

Egypt’s fundamentalist Salafists won a quarter of the seats in the new assembly. Relying on rural support, the Salafists want the nation run under Koranic Sharia law, a view opposed by most urban Egyptians and the nations nine million Coptic Christians.

The Salafists and their Nour Party are also focused on local issues. They may be unable to compromise with the more moderate Brotherhood, and even become antagonistic.

The rest of the seats were won by the venerable, liberal Wafd Party, and some young, western-oriented independents. Their influence will be minimal.

Egypt’s new parliament must now face the difficult task of naming a 100-member panel to draft a new constitution to then be validated by a national referendum.

Even if parliament achieves this goal, it will then confront Egypt’s 500,000-man military and equally numerous internal security forces. So far, Egypt’s military, which is financed, armed and sustained by Washington, threw dictator Mubarak to the wolves to appease popular anger but has barely given an inch on other key issues.

A year after the Tahrir Square revolution, Egypt remains a brutal police state where regime critics disappear, are tortured, and jailed in the thousands. The old guard still control much of the nation’s media, academia, courts and industry: Mubarakism without Mubarak.

The US-backed generals own between a third and two thirds of Egypt’s key businesses or real estate and enjoy lavish perks.

The military’s senior military officers have been trained by the US, vetted by CIA, and are joined at the hip to the Pentagon in much the same manner as were Latin America’s generals in the 60’s and 70’s.

Washington gives Egypt’s military $1.3 billion annually, controls its flow of weapons and spare parts, and provides tens of millions in “black payments” to the military, security forces, and intelligence service, the “Mukhabarat.”

Accordingly, it’s difficult to see Egypt’s plutocratic military easily giving up all of its political and economic power to a rowdy civilian parliament, particularly when the US, Britain, Saudi Arabia, France, and Israel are all quietly backing the military regime.

If the military cracks down on parliamentary forces, it risks driving the opposition underground and more violence. Egypt’s military may split, as younger, Nasserite-officers try to seize power, or face bloody urban guerilla war.

Washington would be wise to press its allies in the military to quickly cede power to a responsible civilian government.

 Copyright Eric S. Margolis 2012

Please note:  The comment section on this site is being suspended, should you wish to direct comments to the writer, send them to:  eric@ericm.org

 

 

Rehmat
Saturday, February 04, 2012 11:21 AM
Israel-Firster Hillary Clinton’s spokeswoman, Victoria Jane Nuland (a Zionist Jew), told reporters on Thursday that leaders of Israel’s most feared Egyptian Islamist party, Muslim Brotherhood, have assured Washington it will honor the 1979 Camp David peace deal with the Zionist regime.

Vitoria, however, down-played Rashad Bayoumi, MB deputy leader’s statement, translated from Arabic by Israeli Memri, that MB will not recognize Israel under “any circumstances”. It’s Memri which coined the term “Ahmadinejad wants to wipe of Israel off map” – even though Ahmadinejad never mentioned word ‘Israel’ in his speech in Persian in 2008. “He is but one member of Muslim Brotherhood. The party will be judged what it does,” said Nuland.

http://rehmat1.wordpress.com/2012/01/07/us-muslim-brotherhood-is-not-anti-israel/
Dino
Saturday, February 04, 2012 2:11 PM
Hello everyone,

this reply is to Mr Margolis mostly, and everyone else reading it.

Usually you are right on the dot, this time got some and missed some. No fear from all the parties in Egypt. As, forgot his name as i am not good with names, stated that USA govt cares not about the names of parties that they have to deal with, all they care is their actions.

So Islamic brotherhood, Sitanic Bro, prono Bro, it does not f*&^%g matter, all the same, Let us see., islamic Bro, rep stated that the brotherhood will respect all treaties signed by previous govts. So take it from there, that was the password.
No conflict or strugle between military and parliment forces. It is required to stay like that till it shows into what direction things go in Syria. All depends on what would happen in Syria. Why till today there is no pm or president in Egypt, and read what took place of Port Said, football game. Creative cahos. It will be sorted out when things are clear in Syria.

All what took place in the ME was a opening and intial start of the game, new ME, and a little shake down. Show the others that even if you were the size of Mubarak, we could take you down in 2 days, and they showed them that. So you stay on borard and follow instructions or face same as Mubarak is facing now.

Arabic Spring, haaa, make me laugh, I would call it Mcdonald Srping. They be able to open alot more stroes in Lybia, Tunisia, marroco, and they hope Syria. But it will not happen.

Either you all give up and bow to the Supreme force or you die warring your brothers in everything.

They will fail, in both. As Isreal failed, the USA will face the same. Not from Countries like Tunisisa, Saudi or Egypt, useless bunch of wosses, generally speaking. It will stop in Syria. They will have a bigger bite than their mouth could take. Time will show
simpleraven
Tuesday, February 07, 2012 4:54 AM
Dino
Which side if the conflict are you supporting?
Michael Lesbowicz
Thursday, February 09, 2012 4:32 PM
Typical juvenile question from an idiotic half-brained imbecile.
Are you trying to decide whether he is a friend or foe?
Not everyone has to choose sides.
I can not blame someone like you for failing to comprehend.
You are after all a simple gentile rat.
Dino
Sunday, February 12, 2012 12:13 PM
Nice going Lesbo wicz, you are the samrt mighty one. God created you ( first, last and unique eddition) you must have three or more balls ( Testicals ) and have 2 brains. Wow, you are the master and God created the rest of us to serve and die serving you.

No ownder there is killing, rape and unjustice in the world and specially around the "masters of the world" world's.
Zieg Hile
There are currently 5 comments
Comments Commentaries
Currently Ordered By:
Commentaries by Category